How can I determine if a company's email is using Gmail or Yahoo under the hood?

Summary

Determining if a company uses Gmail or Yahoo "under the hood" primarily involves analyzing their DNS records, particularly MX records. MX records indicate the mail servers responsible for receiving emails, providing a direct indicator of the email service provider. Tools like MXToolbox, whatsmydns.net, and online command-line utilities such as `nslookup` are useful for checking MX records. If the MX records point to Google servers (e.g., ASPMX.L.GOOGLE.COM), the company likely uses Google Workspace. In addition to MX records, SPF records list authorized sending systems. For white-label services, a deeper investigation into IP addresses, reverse DNS lookups, and certificate ownership may be necessary. Email headers can also provide hints about the sending server. It's important to remember that while MX records are definitive for inbound email routing, senders can sometimes obfuscate sending servers.

Key findings

  • MX Records: Key Indicator: MX records are the most reliable method for identifying the email service provider (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.).
  • Tools for MX Lookup: Tools like MXToolbox, whatsmydns.net, and command-line utilities like `nslookup` simplify the process of checking MX records.
  • SPF Records for Sending Systems: SPF records list authorized sending systems associated with the domain.
  • White-label Challenges: Identifying white-label email services requires deeper investigation beyond MX records.
  • Email Headers Clues: Email headers (e.g., 'Received:' headers) can offer clues about the sending server, complementing MX record analysis.

Key considerations

  • MX Record Accuracy: Ensure accurate MX record interpretation as it directly reflects the receiving mail server.
  • White-label Complexity: Identifying white-label services can be complex and may not always provide a definitive answer, requiring advanced techniques.
  • Obfuscation: Senders can obfuscate sending servers, so relying solely on MX records might not be sufficient; headers and other methods can help.
  • Domain Configuration: Understanding domain configuration and email setup is essential for accurate identification.
  • Third-party Services: Recognize that companies may utilize third-party email services even with a custom domain.

What email marketers say
11Marketer opinions

Determining if a company uses Gmail or Yahoo 'under the hood' involves checking their email configuration. Key methods include examining MX records using tools like MXToolbox or command-line utilities such as `nslookup`. These records point to the mail servers used by the domain, revealing if they use Google Workspace, Yahoo, or another provider. Analyzing email headers and performing reverse DNS lookups on mail server IPs can also provide clues. It's important to note that while MX records are definitive for where emails are received, senders can obfuscate sending servers. Domain ownership and email configuration updates also play a role.

Key opinions

  • MX Records: MX records are the most reliable method to determine which email provider a company uses. They point to the servers responsible for receiving emails for the domain.
  • Email Headers: Email headers can provide hints about the sending server. Examining the 'Received:' headers may reveal the server's name, indicating Gmail, Yahoo, or another provider.
  • Reverse DNS Lookup: Performing a reverse DNS lookup on the mail server's IP address can identify the organization owning the IP, often corresponding to the email provider.
  • Online Tools: Online tools such as MXToolbox, whatsmydns.net, and centralops.net can simplify the process of looking up MX records and DNS information.

Key considerations

  • MX Record Accuracy: Ensure the accuracy of MX records, as they provide a direct indication of the email service provider in use.
  • Obfuscation: Senders might obfuscate sending servers, so additional methods like examining headers may be necessary.
  • Domain Ownership: Configuring a custom email address involves updating MX records to ensure proper email delivery.
  • Configuration: Updating MX records are essential for custom email configurations.
Marketer view

Email marketer from Zoho explains that you can configure a custom email address and then you need to update your MX records for it to work.

November 2022 - Zoho
Marketer view

Email marketer from Reddit suggests performing a reverse DNS lookup on the IP address of the mail server. This can reveal the organization that owns the IP, which often corresponds to the email provider.

January 2024 - Reddit
Marketer view

Marketer from Email Geeks shares a command line script to find the host of an email domain.

December 2021 - Email Geeks
Marketer view

Email marketer from Stack Overflow explains that you can use `nslookup -type=mx domain.com` to find the mail exchange server for a domain, which will often indicate if they are using Google Apps (now Workspace) based on the MX record values.

November 2022 - Stack Overflow
Marketer view

Email marketer from Namecheap explains if you have a domain name then most email providers can be used to send emails under that domain name. These include private email, shared hosting, VPS and dedicated servers or through using a third party like Google Workspace or Microsoft 365.

September 2023 - Namecheap
Marketer view

Email marketer from Reddit says that you can use online tools like `whatsmydns.net` or `centralops.net` to look up MX records and other DNS information, and the MX records would be the most reliable way to see what service they are using.

June 2021 - Reddit
Marketer view

Email marketer from Reddit explains that examining the email headers can reveal the sending server. Headers like 'Received:' often include the server name, which can hint at whether it's Gmail, Yahoo, or another provider.

August 2021 - Reddit
Marketer view

Email marketer from Super User responds that the MX records are the definitive method to find the mail server provider. While the user can hide who sends the emails, they can not hide where to send emails. It is possible for companies to relay through their own system and obfuscate the final sending server.

September 2023 - Super User
Marketer view

Marketer from Email Geeks shares that you can check the MX record with a tool and mentions Alfred product, Inbox Monster and Validity also offer this feature in their list analyzers.

March 2023 - Email Geeks
Marketer view

Email marketer from DigitalOcean shares that the MX records are used to route emails to the correct servers, so checking these will let you see who is hosting the emails.

August 2022 - DigitalOcean
Marketer view

Email marketer from Whois explains that you can perform an MX Lookup and enter the domain name you would like to find the host for. This will provide the hostname and the IP address.

April 2023 - Whois

What the experts say
3Expert opinions

To determine if a company's email uses Gmail or Yahoo, experts recommend examining DNS records, particularly MX and SPF records. The MX record reveals the receiving mail server, while the SPF record indicates authorized sending systems. Identifying white-label services requires a deeper investigation, including checking IP addresses, reverse DNS, IP block ownership, server banners, and TLS certificate ownership. Tools like MXToolbox, whatsmydns.com, and HostedEmail.com can assist in identifying the email provider.

Key opinions

  • MX Record: MX records reveal the receiving mail server and can directly indicate if a company uses Gmail or Yahoo.
  • SPF Record: SPF records list authorized sending systems.
  • White-label Services: Identifying white-label services requires investigating IP addresses, reverse DNS, and certificate ownership.
  • Tools: Tools like MXToolbox, whatsmydns.com, and HostedEmail.com are useful for checking DNS records.

Key considerations

  • Complexity: Identifying white-label services can be complex and may not always yield a definitive answer.
  • Data Availability: The effectiveness of these methods depends on the completeness and accuracy of the available DNS records.
  • Multiple providers: A company may use multiple email providers, making identification more challenging.
Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks shares that for whitelabel services, you may need to investigate IP addresses, reverse DNS, IP block ownership, server banners, and TLS certificate ownership to identify the actual provider.

March 2021 - Email Geeks
Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks explains that the sending systems are in the SPF record and receiving system is in the MX record.

November 2021 - Email Geeks
Expert view

Expert from Word to the Wise explains that the MX records will show which provider they are using and tools such as MXToolbox, whatsmydns or HostedEmail.com can be used to provide this information.

June 2022 - Word to the Wise

What the documentation says
3Technical articles

Documentation indicates that to determine if a company uses Gmail or Yahoo for email, you should check their MX records. If the MX records point to Google servers (e.g., ASPMX.L.GOOGLE.COM), they likely use Google Workspace. MX Lookup tools, such as the one provided by MXToolbox, can be used to view these records. Business email hosts generally fall into categories like Self-Hosted, Email Hosting Providers, or Hosted Email Services, with Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 being prominent examples of the latter.

Key findings

  • MX Records for Google: If a company's MX records point to Google servers (e.g., ASPMX.L.GOOGLE.COM), they are likely using Google Workspace.
  • MX Lookup Tools: MX Lookup tools (e.g., MXToolbox) can be used to view a domain's MX records to identify their email provider.
  • Hosted Email Services: Business email hosting options include self-hosted solutions, email hosting providers, and hosted email services (like Google Workspace and Microsoft 365).

Key considerations

  • MX Record Interpretation: Understanding and correctly interpreting MX records is crucial for identifying the email provider.
  • Tool Usage: Familiarity with MX Lookup tools can streamline the process of checking MX records.
  • Hosting Variety: Companies have a range of options for email hosting, so relying solely on one factor may not be definitive.
Technical article

Documentation from Google Admin Toolbox shares that the MX records should point to Google servers such as ASPMX.L.GOOGLE.COM if they are using Google Workspace. You can use the MX Lookup tool to check these records.

July 2024 - Google Admin Toolbox
Technical article

Documentation from MXToolbox explains that using their MX Lookup tool, you can enter a domain name and it will show you the MX records, which can help determine if the domain uses Google Workspace, Yahoo, or another email provider.

March 2024 - MXToolbox
Technical article

Documentation from KDnuggets outlines the various options for a business email host. These are split into three groups, Self-Hosted, Email Hosting Provider and Hosted Email Services. Hosted Email Services are Gmail (Google Workspace) or Outlook (Microsoft 365).

November 2022 - KDnuggets