How to troubleshoot MX record issues with Cloudflare when one domain bounces?

7 Marketer opinions 7 Expert opinions 7 Technical articles 6 Resources

Summary

Troubleshooting MX record issues with Cloudflare when email bounces to a single domain involves a multi-faceted approach. Key areas to investigate include DNS caching, propagation delays, potential conflicts with Cloudflare's proxy and page rules, and the accuracy of MX record configurations. Utilizing diagnostic tools like `dig`, `nslookup`, and MXToolbox is essential for analyzing DNS settings and identifying discrepancies. It's also crucial to consider factors external to Cloudflare, such as the recipient domain's DNS configuration, the sending server's blacklist status, and DMARC policy settings. Understanding DNS error messages and using graphical analysis tools like DNSViz can aid in pinpointing misconfigurations. If bounces persist only to one domain, the recipient's DNS settings and potential server blocking should be examined closely.

Key findings

DNS Caching & Propagation: Cached incorrect MX records after updates and DNS propagation delays can lead to inconsistent resolution across servers.
Cloudflare Interference: Cloudflare's proxy, page rules, and DNS settings may inadvertently interfere with MX record resolution, causing delivery issues.
MX Record Configuration: Incorrectly configured MX records (typos, incorrect priority, or non-compliant RFC formatting) can lead to delivery failures.
Conflicting DNS Records: Conflicting DNS records, especially A records pointing to the same domain as MX records, can create resolution problems.
External Factors: The sending server's IP address being blacklisted or unusual DNS configurations on the recipient domain can cause bounces.
Authoritative Server Issues: Cloudflare might refuse to answer DNS queries directly or have issues with the authoritative server itself.
DMARC Policy: Overly strict DMARC policies, combined with SPF and DKIM misalignment, can trigger email rejections.

Key considerations

Double-Check Configurations: Thoroughly verify all MX record settings in Cloudflare and ensure they align with the intended mail server configuration.
Monitor DNS Propagation: Use global DNS propagation checkers to monitor the visibility of DNS changes and promptly address any inconsistencies.
Isolate the Issue: Determine if the problem is localized to a single recipient domain or a widespread issue to guide troubleshooting efforts.
Utilize Diagnostic Tools: Employ a combination of command-line tools (dig, nslookup) and online diagnostic platforms (MXToolbox, DNSViz) for in-depth DNS analysis.
Examine Recipient DNS: When bounces occur only to one domain, examine their DNS settings and potential server-side blocking configurations.
Address Blacklisting: Proactively check the sending server's IP address against blacklists and take steps to remediate if necessary.
Understand DNS Errors: Familiarize yourself with common DNS error messages to quickly diagnose misconfigurations and resolve them effectively.

What email marketers say
7Marketer opinions

When troubleshooting MX record issues with Cloudflare that cause bounces to only one domain, several factors should be investigated. DNS propagation delays, TTL values, and potential interference from Cloudflare's proxy and page rules should be considered. Verifying the sending server's IP isn't blacklisted, checking for unusual DNS configurations on the receiving domain, and utilizing tools like `dig` and `nslookup` for direct DNS queries are also recommended.

Key opinions

DNS Propagation: DNS propagation delays might cause inconsistencies, leading to bounces for specific domains. Clearing local DNS cache or using a public DNS server can help.
Cloudflare Proxy: Cloudflare's proxy and page rules might interfere with DNS settings. Excluding the affected subdomain from the proxy ('DNS only' setting) can resolve issues.
DNS Tools: Using tools like `dig` and `nslookup` is crucial for direct DNS record queries to identify discrepancies.
TTL Values: TTL values affect DNS record propagation speed. Lower TTL values result in faster updates but may increase DNS query load.
Blacklisting: The sending server's IP address being blacklisted can cause delivery failures. Online blacklist checkers should be used to verify.
Unusual DNS Configs: The receiving domain may have unusual DNS configurations or security policies that lead to conflicts.
Page Rules: Cloudflare Page Rules could inadvertently override DNS settings, leading to delivery problems.

Key considerations

Propagation Time: Allow sufficient time for DNS changes to propagate across the internet. This can vary depending on TTL settings and DNS server caching.
Configuration Conflicts: Carefully review Cloudflare settings, including proxy status and page rules, to ensure they don't conflict with DNS records.
External Factors: Consider external factors like blacklisting and the recipient domain's unique DNS policies, as they can significantly impact deliverability.
Thorough Testing: Perform comprehensive testing after making changes to ensure email delivery is successful to all intended recipients.

Marketer view

Email marketer from Email Provider Forum suggests checking if your mail server's IP address is blacklisted. Being blacklisted can cause delivery failures to certain domains. Use online blacklist checkers to verify.

March 2021 - Email Provider Forum

Marketer view

Email marketer from Reddit suggests excluding the affected subdomain from Cloudflare's proxy. By setting the DNS record to 'DNS only' (grey cloud), you bypass Cloudflare's caching and security features for that subdomain, potentially resolving DNS issues.

April 2023 - Reddit

Marketer view

Email marketer from Cloudflare Community shares that if the domain is using Cloudflare's proxy, check if a Page Rule is inadvertently interfering with the DNS settings. A misconfigured Page Rule can override DNS configurations and cause delivery issues.

February 2023 - Cloudflare Community

Marketer view

Email marketer from DNS Discussion Forum recommends checking for unusual DNS configurations or edge cases specific to the bouncing domain. Some domains might have unique security policies or DNS settings that cause conflicts.

November 2023 - DNS Discussion Forum

Marketer view

Email marketer from Super User recommends using online tools like `dig` or `nslookup` to query DNS records directly. These tools can provide detailed information about how DNS is resolving the MX records and identify discrepancies.

May 2022 - Super User

Marketer view

Email marketer from Webmaster Forum shares that the Time-To-Live (TTL) value of your DNS records affects how quickly changes propagate. Lower TTL values result in faster updates but can increase DNS query load. Check TTL settings in Cloudflare.

November 2021 - Webmaster Forum

Marketer view

Email marketer from Stack Overflow shares that it may be DNS propagation delays. Even if Cloudflare is configured correctly, some DNS servers might take time to update, causing inconsistencies for certain domains. Clear your local DNS cache or use a public DNS server to check.

August 2021 - Stack Overflow

What the experts say
7Expert opinions

Troubleshooting MX record issues with Cloudflare when email bounces to only one domain requires examining several potential causes. DNS caching of incorrect records after updates can lead to inconsistent results across DNS servers. Identifying the authoritative server using tools like `dig hostname NS` is essential. It's important to check if Cloudflare is refusing to answer DNS queries. Often, the bouncing issue originates from the recipient's side, where misconfigured DNS settings or server blocking could be at fault. Graphical DNS analysis using DNSViz can help visualize problems, and understanding specific DNS error messages assists in diagnosis. Misconfigured DNS servers are frequently the root cause of these errors.

Key opinions

DNS Caching: Typoing an MX record during update can cause caching of incorrect info and lead to inconsistencies.
Authoritative Server Identification: Tools like `dig hostname NS` helps determine the authoritative server.
Cloudflare Refusal: Cloudflare could be refusing DNS queries directly to its nameservers.
Recipient-Side Issues: Bouncing could arise from misconfigured DNS or server blocking on the recipient's side.
DNSViz Analysis: DNSViz tool helps graphically visualize and analyze DNS setups.
Error Message Understanding: Deciphering DNS error messages are crucial for diagnosis.
DNS Misconfiguration: Misconfigured DNS servers are a common cause of DNS issues.

Key considerations

Check for Typos: Always double-check MX records for typos during updates and ensure they are correctly configured.
Verify DNS Servers: Verify DNS server configurations and make sure they are correctly answering queries.
Investigate Recipient Settings: If bounces are limited to one recipient, thoroughly investigate their DNS settings and potential server blocks.
Use Diagnostic Tools: Use a combination of command-line and graphical tools to analyze the DNS setup and identify potential issues.

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks explains that if you typo an MX update and then fix it, the bad one can be cached, leading to different DNS servers returning different results.

September 2022 - Email Geeks

Expert view

Expert from Spam Resource explains that DNS errors are often due to DNS server misconfiguration. Understanding specific error messages is key to diagnosing the issue.

October 2021 - Spam Resource

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks suggests using `dig hostname NS` to identify the authoritative server for an MX record.

October 2024 - Email Geeks

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks explains that Cloudflare might be refusing to answer queries for the domain or is returning a 'refused' status when queried directly at the Cloudflare nameservers.

December 2023 - Email Geeks

Expert view

Expert from Word to the Wise emphasizes that if a client is bouncing to only one place, the problem is likely on their end, and it is important to check that they have DNS set up correctly and are not blocking your server.

January 2024 - Word to the Wise

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks confirms Laura's assessment that there's an issue with the authoritative server, using a DNS tool to demonstrate the problem.

February 2023 - Email Geeks

Expert view

Expert from Word to the Wise recommends using DNSViz to graphically see the DNS setup and potential issues.

June 2024 - Word to the Wise

What the documentation says
7Technical articles

Troubleshooting MX record issues in Cloudflare that result in bounces to a single domain involves verifying the correct configuration of MX records, ensuring they point to the appropriate mail server with the correct priority. Utilize DNS lookup tools to check for proper resolution and propagation, considering that propagation delays can affect some domains. Look for conflicting DNS records, particularly A records, and confirm adherence to the correct MX record format as per RFC standards. Employ diagnostic tools like MXToolbox for comprehensive DNS analysis and global DNS propagation checkers to identify regional caching problems. Furthermore, review DMARC policies to avoid overly strict settings that might cause email delivery failures if SPF and DKIM records aren't aligned.

Key findings

MX Record Configuration: MX records must be correctly configured in Cloudflare, pointing to the right mail server with the correct priority.
DNS Propagation: Use DNS lookup tools to confirm MX records are resolving as expected, identifying propagation issues.
Conflicting Records: Conflicting DNS records, especially A records, can interfere with MX record functionality.
RFC Compliance: MX records must adhere to the correct format, as defined in RFC standards, including priority and FQDN.
Diagnostic Tools: MXToolbox provides diagnostic tools for analyzing DNS configurations and identifying errors.
Global Propagation Check: Global DNS propagation checkers help ensure updated MX records are visible worldwide, addressing regional caching issues.
DMARC Policy: Overly strict DMARC policies can lead to delivery failures if SPF and DKIM are not properly aligned.

Key considerations

Verify Settings: Double-check all MX record settings in Cloudflare to ensure accuracy and alignment with your mail server configuration.
Monitor Propagation: Regularly monitor DNS propagation using various tools to catch and address any inconsistencies.
Review DNS Records: Periodically review DNS records for potential conflicts that could disrupt email delivery.
Adjust DMARC Policy: Assess and adjust DMARC policies to balance security and deliverability, ensuring SPF and DKIM alignment.

Technical article

Documentation from MXToolbox explains using diagnostic tools such as the MX Lookup Tool on MXToolbox to analyze the DNS configuration and identify errors or inconsistencies. These tools provide a comprehensive overview of DNS settings.

April 2023 - MXToolbox

Technical article

Documentation from Google states that to confirm MX records propagate correctly, use a DNS lookup tool to check if the records are resolving as expected. This helps identify if the issue is with DNS propagation.

February 2023 - Google

Technical article

Documentation from DNSChecker.org says to use global DNS propagation checkers to ensure that the updated MX records are visible from various locations worldwide. This helps identify regional DNS caching issues that may affect only some users.

December 2022 - DNSChecker.org

Technical article

Documentation from Cloudflare explains to verify the MX records are correctly configured in your Cloudflare DNS settings. Ensure they point to your mail server and have the correct priority.

August 2024 - Cloudflare

Technical article

Documentation from EasyDMARC explains that if you have a DMARC policy configured for your domain, ensure it is not set too strict (e.g., p=reject) which could cause email delivery failures if the SPF and DKIM records are not properly aligned.

August 2021 - EasyDMARC

Technical article

Documentation from RFC states that confirm the MX record format is correct. It should include the priority and the fully qualified domain name of the mail server. Incorrect formatting will cause failures.

December 2023 - RFC

Technical article

Documentation from DigitalOcean explains that conflicting DNS records, especially A records pointing to the same domain as MX records, can cause issues. Ensure that only the mail server's IP is associated with the MX record.

June 2021 - DigitalOcean

Some emails getting bounced back through Gmail - Getting Started ...

We joined Cloudflare last month. Some of our emails go through GSuite, and we have not seen any issues with them, however we are having continuing problems sending and receiving emails through non-GSuite gmail accounts. Initially the issue was with not being able to get them at all, we solved that by changing the mailserver names as shown here: Cloudflare Not Connecting to Gmail Email - #2 by alecrose55 And using the DNS flush tool recommended here: GMail Delivery failing after switching to C...

Cloudflare Community

DNS issue, MX Error - Email sending not working - Virtualmin ...

SYSTEM INFORMATION OS type and version: centos 7 Webmin version: Latest Virtualmin version: Latest Related products version: Cloud-flare I am using contabo server, after change the name-server of the server (new name server name is we.robotlancer. com), i think lots of problem arrived. main problem is our emails not working. I am using VPS, Cloudflare (i am using 2 domain gocloudo. com and robotlancer. com) Online tools report - intoDNS: gocloudo.com - check DNS server an...

Virtualmin Community

MX record on sub-domain does not resolve correctly - DNS ...

Hi there, I have a weird issue with an Microsoft 365 account on a sub-domain. I’ve been going around in circles with Microsoft support for weeks, but they are not very helpful. We manage 100s of tenants in our Partner Portal and never had a problem like this. We set up a 365 account and add a sub-domain to the account and then create a few email addresses on that sub-domain. The problem is that any email sent to those addresses does not resolve properly, although everything seems to be set up...

Cloudflare Community

I've added an MX record for Plesk server and mail headed ...

I’m running a web server with a domain on Plesk. In the Plesk instructions for the mail section it says to ad an MX record at your DNS provider for the domain name. I have done that, and before I did that all the mail headed to that server was bounced, now that the MX is there the mail just disappears. I should ad that the Plesk mail server is simply setup to forward mail to my personal email account - so the issue is not the Plesk server at this time. I’m just starting by trying to get the ma...

Cloudflare Community

Cloudflare- SMTP Email Bounce-backs - Getting Started - Cloudflare ...

Hello all! I am new to Cloudflare and am using it to help boost speed of a wordpress site run by inmotion hosting. Speed and optimization have been great but I have run into some issues with our domain hosted email being bounced back repetitively. I did some research and added an MX record with our mail domain alongside the server inmotion provided me with when we were having email troubles in the past. Can you think of any other troubleshooting hacks to try? I appreciate any and all help!

Cloudflare Community